Coal seam gas: climate disaster brought to you by the carbon tax

The coal seam gas (CSG) industry is rapidly expanding across the country. There are even efforts to drill for CSG in central Sydney. Labor’s carbon tax is encouraging the gas rush. But it’s a disaster for the climate.

Climate Change Minister Greg Combet has described gas as a “cleaner energy source” and mining and gas companies argue that gas power generates fewer emissions than coal-fired power. That’s only true if you take into account the emissions from the power stations alone. As Melbourne Energy Institute researcher Patrick Hearps has said, “Taking into consideration the total life cycle emissions of coal seam gas, particularly methane, its emissions intensity is likely to be a lot closer to coal fired power.”

During coal seam gas mining, methane, a potent greenhouse gas, leaks out at a higher level than during conventional gas extraction. Not only that, the extraction process is an environmental disaster. The process, “fracking”, involves pumping toxic chemicals into the ground in order to force out gas.

CSG production increased by 32 per cent a year between 2003 and 2008. Greg Combet wants more. He told Lateline in March that the carbon price is designed to encourage investment in gas. In the face of climate change, this is an insane policy. Labor could be rapidly expanding investment in renewables and providing thousands of green jobs.

Yet wind energy makes up less than 1 per cent of Australia’s energy use; despite the fact that Beyond Zero Emissions estimates it could produce 40 per cent of our power. Spain is building enough solar power plants in the next three years to replace two of NSW’s largest coal power stations, Bayswater and Mt Piper. Storage technology allows them to produce power 24 hours a day.

Labor’s priorities are skewed by their determination to protect the profits of the coal and gas industries. The $10 billion from carbon tax revenue going to a Clean Energy Finance Corporation won’t deliver any renewable energy beyond what will already be delivered by the Mandatory Renewable Energy Target.

Opposition to CSG is growing amongst farmers in NSW and Queensland whose land is threatened by the expansion. But the fight to stop CSG is tied to the fight against policies like the carbon tax.

Instead of a policy that encourages more fossil fuels while slugging us on our electricity bills, we could fight for government investment in renewables. The NSW Greens calculate three small solar thermal power stations could be built for $2 billion each. This is the sort of alternative to coal seam gas and the carbon tax that we need.

By James Supple


Solidarity meetings

Latest articles

Read more

Labor’s coal expansion fuels climate breakdown

“Climate breakdown has begun,” the UN’s Antonio Guterres has declared, after the world’s hottest three months on record.

Unions step up support for Gomeroi against Santos gas project

Over 200 trade unionists and supporters joined a “rally and road trip” in the Pilliga in north-west NSW on 12 August, supporting Gomeroi in their fight against Santos’ Pilliga-Narrabri gas project.

Workers left exposed as fires and extreme heat circle the globe

Heatwaves and wildfires have been raging across the northern hemisphere. July was the hottest month ever recorded.


  1. Before ranting about CSG, please do some basic homework and get some facts. If you compare lifecycle emissions and envirnomental damage on CSG, then do the same comparison for other forms of energy. You will find that coal mining, both open pit and underground have been venting methane for decades in order to de-gas and make safe. You will find the envirnomental damage from solar and wind comes from mining the precious metals, then manufacture and installation. Oh sure, once running, its “clean and green”, but what about counting all the envirnonmental damage to get there. And don’t forget about re-manufacture after a 10-20 usefull life; they don’t work forever. Don’t forget about all the gas that is flared worldwide so people can run vehicles and equipment on petrol and diesel from the Middle East, when we could fuel these vehicles on Australian gas. And what about those frac treatments that only use formation water and sand, yes shut those down too. And don’t mention that the “toxic chemicals” used in fracs before the BTEX ban already had less BTEX than a Diet Coke. So if you really want to help make this a better place, then do something than recycle old propoganda.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here