Coronavirus─the myth that we’re ‘all in it together’

“There are no more unions or bosses. There are just Australians now.” So said Scott Morrison last week.

Morrison, like national leaders around the world, says we are “all in it together” during the coronavirus pandemic and the economic crisis it has precipitated. According to him, bosses, workers, landlords and tenants will all be called on to make sacrifices in the name of “Team Australia”.

The Labor Party and sections of the union movement are also calling for greater cooperation with bosses to “save jobs” and Australian businesses.

Former ACTU president and Labor minister Simon Crean called on workers, businesses and the government to come together to plot a way forward. ACTU Secretary Sally McManus has been having regular video conferences with Liberal Industrial Relations Minister Christian Porter, who has spent the last few years trying to destroy the union movement.

Asked about their new working relationship, Porter said, “if you told me I was going to be BFF with Sally McManus three weeks ago, I wouldn’t have believed you.”

But Morrison’s stimulus measures are aimed at saving businesses, not protecting workers’ living standards.

His “Job Keeper” wage subsidy provides payments at the minimum wage to allow companies to keep workers employed. The aim, Morrison says, is “keeping… businesses together”, so they can rebound when the crisis passes.

But it does nothing to force them to keep workers employed on the other side. There is no guarantee workers will still have a job after six months when the payment expires.

And many workers have been left out—including one million casual workers employed for less than 12 months (although some might benefit from last minute changes) as well as the 1.1 million migrant workers on temporary visas and refugees and asylum seekers on Temporary Protection Visas or bridging visas.

Many workers will also take a hefty pay cut, as there is nothing to compel bosses to make up the difference between the payment and workers’ original pay.

Qantas was handed a $715 million government bail-out only to stand down 20,000 workers the following day. The government made no effort to force them to maintain workers’ pay.

Those on welfare will have to spend five weeks living on $40 a day before the doubling of the measly JobSeeker payment kicks in.

And Melbourne University executives that earn a combined $7.5 million have been firing casual staff via email in recent days.

Even the experience of becoming sick with coronavirus is different for the rich than it is for the rest of us. While Tom Hanks and Peter Dutton received test results and treatment immediately, many others were waiting a week to find out their test results, if they were even eligible for a test. Nurses and health workers are warning of a severe shortage of protective gear, meaning they risk becoming sick almost daily.


A number of unions have accepted changes to workplace agreements cutting wages and working hours.

The United Workers Union (UWU) struck a deal with the Australian Hotels Association to vary the Hospitality Award and allow bosses to reduce employees’ hours and direct them at short notice to take annual leave at half pay for three months. Unions have agreed to similar changes to the Restaurant Award and Clerks Award, covering 1.5 million admin workers.

Allowing workers’ wages and conditions to be attacked is a huge mistake and sets a dangerous precedent for the oncoming recession.

Bosses are already pushing for further attacks. The Australian Mines and Metals Association has written to the government calling for all Awards and Enterprise Agreements to be suspended for six months, removing all working conditions and wage rates. Small business groups have called for an end to unfair dismissal claims for six months.

Rather than compromising with the bosses, there needs to be a fight to defend jobs, as well as our hard-earned conditions.

There have been some inspiring examples of this. NTEU members have won paid sick leave for casuals, and are continuing to fight for casual staff to be paid during university shutdowns. UWU members in warehouses have walked off the jobs over lack of safety measures. Much more of this is needed.

Bailing out the rich

The idea that workers and bosses are “in it together” arises from the idea that we have a common, national interest. This is a myth.

During every serious economic crisis the rich try to force the cost onto workers.

The Retail Association is already calling for a 12 month freeze in the minimum wage—effectively a wage cut after inflation. This mirrors the way wages were frozen at the time of the GFC.

But when the minimum wage was cut by 10 per cent during the Depression, unemployment levels remained the same as bosses pocketed the savings.

All over the world workers are still suffering from the austerity introduced to “rescue” economies after the GFC. Meanwhile, the top 1 per cent now own more than half the world’s wealth.

In Australia, after the economic crisis of the late 1970s, unions, business and government came together to design the Prices and Incomes Accord. This slashed wages and drastically reduced union power, laying the groundwork for the harsh anti-strike laws we face today.

If the coronavirus crisis has shown anything, it is that none of the “essential work” done under capitalism—healthcare, food services, deliveries, teaching, research, IT, media production—is done by billionaire bosses or landlords.

Australian workers have far more in common with the 1.1 million migrant workers and international students who will miss out on any extra financial support during this period than we do with the “Aussie” bosses who preside over us.

CEOs like Alan Joyce are only interested in shoring up the profits of their own team—the Bosses’ Team.

The coronavirus crisis is going to deepen the division between those at the top and the rest of us.

Rather than trying to smooth over those divisions, unions and workers need to fight the bosses every step of the way, not only to defend our existing conditions, but to win real, lasting changes to society.

By Caitlin Doyle


Solidarity meetings

Latest articles

Read more

Brotherhood campaign ends with sector-leading enterprise agreement and stronger union

Workers at the Brotherhood of St Laurence in Melbourne have voted up a new enterprise agreement, ending 16 months of bargaining that saw strikes for the first time in the 93-year-old anti-poverty charity’s history.

Ingham’s strikes show the way to fight for real wage rises

There was a determined and celebratory mood last Friday morning among hundreds of workers picketing the Ingham’s Burton poultry plant on Kaurna land in northern Adelaide.

Time to hunt building bosses, not ducks

Instead of talk about duck hunting, the unions should be doing something about the 50 and 60-hour weeks that are the rule on construction sites.


  1. This is a rare example of truly “independent” journalism amid the current crisis.
    Of course, the “Murdochracy” will concentrate on looking to the immediate future post- the crisis when Mr Morrison can get back to situation normal, neoliberalism rulz ok?
    The two soft-neoliberal papers, The SMH and The Guardian will continue to point to certain hassles amid the detritus of the purposely precarious economy that has been fashioned by neoliberal tenets presented by the TWO wings of neoliberal government, Liberal and Labor. But they still expect it to “reset” to a “precariat” yet again and will accede to its inevitability.
    We are a mirror of the American experience, albeit with some of the “back-silvering” worn, saving us from the worst of the US. But only the very worst.
    The US, of course, STILL has a deliberately self-nobbling Democratic Party farcically putting up lame-duck candidates to preserve the neoliberal consensus… versus the extreme nonsense propagated by the Trumpeting Republicans. Wot a choice.
    And recently Mr Albanese has been worrying about the Liberals spending so much… a funny sort of parody of the Liberals’ worrying about Mr Rudd’s largesse during the last Neoliberal Embarrassment. And to make matters worse, STILL implying the same absurd (neoliberal) nonsense that the home budget can be viewed as the same as the National Budget, despite the latter having the right to generate its own (fiat) currency… and the household budget just a little different if it tried the same, the police being potentially interested!
    Very little will change given the “stern examination” that Labor will subject Scotty’s crowd to after the plague. Lots of little identity bits with very little examination of the taxation recalcitrance and corporate free kicks to which Australia will once again be subjected. Labor will still ignore the machinations of unions such as the SDA concentrating more on abortions than members’ wages and conditions. TINA will still reign. There will still be no alternative.

  2. On oh so many occasions in the recent past “experts” have pushed for an increase in the GST. “Experts” like heads of banks (recently caught indulging in dodgy practices upon their customers) also “urged” government (repeatedly, ad nauseam) to spread the load upon the average Joe with a concomitant new swathe of tax cuts for the top, both incomes and corporate.
    In other words, yet another increase in a REGRESSIVE tax and a decrease in an already gutted progressive tax.
    And today the more quietly neoliberal Guardian has bestowed the “expert” title upon the first but tediously predictable “expert” who wants a hike in the GST. For the Coronavirus debacle.
    Never let a crisis go unexploited. Especially if you’re talking on behalf of the wealthy who have the ear of both sides of parliament.
    And then, surprise! Let it become… sort of… “permanent”.
    And then, no doubt, surprise No 2! More especially enhanced tax cuts for the top and and a handsome reduction in corporate tax!
    Every neoliberal government since (and including) Hawkie would be proud of this gem of fiscal action in the Corona of neoliberal government in Australia.
    All utterly predictable, and quietly accepted by the mainstream media with that ultimate of all weasel words, “expert”.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here