Labor’s attack on 457 workers is racist scapegoating

Bill Shorten has stepped up his attack on 457 visas in the wake of Trump’s election in the US.

Drawing the conclusion that xenophobia is the key to winning support amongst workers, he declared, “We’re not going to lose our blue-collar voters like the Democrats did.”

Shorten has blamed migrant workers for unemployment, claiming temporary workers from overseas are, “taking the jobs of nurses, motor mechanics, carpenters, auto-electricians”.

In words that could have come from the mouth of Trump, Shorten declared, “We will buy Australian, build Australian, make in Australia and employ Australians”.

Both Labor and The Greens moved amendments to Turnbull’s ABCC legislation designed to make it harder to employ 457 visa workers in the construction industry. The Greens openly declared this was an attempt to see if racist Pauline Hanson was “serious” about putting curbs on foreign workers.

This is a dagger to the heart of union organising in a country with such a large migrant population.

If local workers think migrants are to blame for stealing jobs and driving down wages this will set us against each other and divide the working class.

There is no clear distinction between temporary and permanent migrants. There are only 94,890 primary 457 visa workers in Australia according to the latest statistics. But 190,000 permanent migrants are accepted every year. Many temporary visa workers will go on to stay here permanently—it is estimated they will make up 70 per cent of the permanent migrants accepted over the next few years.

Bosses do try to exploit migrant workers and employ them on poor wages and conditions. The solution to this is to organise them into the unions and fight to demand better conditions, not to campaign against them coming here.

The Coalition responded with a disgraceful move to reduce the period 457 workers are allowed to remain in the country if they lose their job. They will now have just 60 days, instead of 90, to find another job or face deportation. This will only make 457 workers even more vulnerable to exploitation, because their boss controls their right to be in the country.

It’s not migrant workers responsible for unemployment and job cuts. Rio Tinto has just announced 500 job cuts in WA. This is driven by the desire to maintain profits. Greedy bosses and government cuts are what is really responsible for unemployment.

By James Supple

Magazine

Solidarity meetings

Latest articles

Read more

Greens lose seats but millions of voters can still be a...

The Greens have suffered a heavy blow in the 2025 election, losing most of their lower house seats and failing to win any new ones.

Labor’s historic vote hides continued major party decline

Labor’s election victory defied expectations, with the Albanese government increasing its majority in the lower house and on track to have the highest number of seats since Bob Hawke’s 1987 win.

Albanese’s talk of ‘Australian values’ masks Labor’s pandering to the rich

A triumphant Anthony Albanese started his victory speech on election night addressing “My fellow Australians”—and went on to invoke Australia no fewer than 43 more times over the next 22 minutes. Values also scored six mentions.